Skip to Main content
Matty's Pizza is back!!
  • Buffalo Brothers Cary

Banner image

Matty's Pizza

109 Main Street, Batavia, NY
Change location
‌
‌
Appetizers
Wings
Pizza
Specialty Pizza
Sides

Featured Items

  • Small Cheese Pizza

    10" Pizza with mozzarella cheese
    $10.50
  • BBQ Chicken

    Buttermilk ranch base with mozzarella and cheddar cheeses, grilled chicken, bacon, and drizzled with BBQ sauce
    $14.00+
  • Mozzarella sticks w\marinara

    5 homemade mozzarella sticks served with warm marinara on side.
    $12.00

Appetizers

  • Stuffed Jalapenos

    Fresh jalapeno peppers stuffed with cream cheese, cheddar, and bacon. Drizzled with hot honey and chipotle ranch dressing
    $9.00
  • Stuffed Mushrooms

    Mushroom caps stuffed with spinach and Artichoke dip topped with mozzarella cheese and baked
    $9.00
  • Spin Art Dip

    creamy dip topped with mozzarella cheese and baked. Served with tortilla chips
    $10.00
  • Mozzarella sticks w\marinara

    5 homemade mozzarella sticks served with warm marinara on side.
    $12.00
  • Tennessee honey mozzarella sticks w\ranch

    our homemade mozzarella sticks dipped in our sweet and spicy Tennessee honey sauce served with a side of ranch for dipping.
    $14.00
  • Hand Battered Tender Platter w/fries(no substitutions)

    5 Hand battered chicken tenders served with fries(no substitutions) and blue cheese. Comes with your choice of dipping sauce on the side.
    $15.00

Wings

  • 10 Chicken Wings

    Ten deep fried chicken wings, tossed in your choice of wing sauce, served with blue cheese dressing.
    $15.00
  • 20 Chicken Wings

    Twenty deep fried chicken wings, tossed in your choice of wing sauce, served with blue cheese dressing.
    $28.00

Pizza

  • Small Cheese Pizza

    10" Pizza with mozzarella cheese
    $10.50
  • Large Cheese Pizza

    14" Pizza with mozzarella cheese
    $17.25

Specialty Pizza

  • Double Decker

    Double decker pizza: thin crust topped with buffalo sauce, crispy chicken and mozzarella, topped with another thin crust, red sauce, more mozzarella and pepperoni.
    $18.00+
  • BBQ Chicken

    Buttermilk ranch base with mozzarella and cheddar cheeses, grilled chicken, bacon, and drizzled with BBQ sauce
    $14.00+
  • Buffalo Chicken

    Blue cheese base with chicken fingers, mozzarella cheese, and medium wing sauce
    $13.00+
  • Ero's Pizza

    Traditional red sauce and mozzarella, topped with pepperoni, ham, and banana peppers
    $13.00+
  • Four Cheese Steak

    Olive oil base with chopped steak, a four cheese blend of mozzarella, Swiss, American, and cheddar. Topped with mushrooms, onions, and banana peppers
    $15.00+
  • Greek

    Ricotta and olive oil base with mozzarella and feta cheese, topped with Greek olive salad, artichoke hearts, tomato, and onion
    $13.00+
  • Hot Piggies

    Traditional red sauce and mozzarella topped with pepperoni, bacon, hot cherry and jalapeno peppers, and drizzled with hot honey
    $13.00+
  • Mac Attack

    White Base with American, cheddar, hamburger, onion, tomato, and 1000 island drizzle. Chilled iceburg lettuce topped after baking
    $13.00+
  • Pickle Pizza

    Ricotta and olive oil base with mozzarella, pickle chips, and fresh dill
    $13.00+
  • Stinger

    Blue cheese base with American Swiss and cheddar cheeses, chicken fingers, and steak. Topped with buffalo sauce drizzle.
    $15.00+
  • Stuffed Pepper

    Ricotta and olive oil base with mozzarella, Hungarian peppers, and Italian sausage
    $13.00+
  • Supreme

    Mozzarella cheese with pepperoni, mushrooms, onion, and Italian sausage
    $13.00+
  • Veggie

    Ricotta and olive oil base with mozzarella, mushroom, black olive, spinach, and tomato
    $13.00+
  • Country Sweet Pizza

    Country sweet, chicken tenders, mozzarella and bacon pieces
    $14.00+
  • Aaron Special

    A-A-Ron special: buffalo-garlic parm sauce for the base, topped with mozzarella cheese and cup and char pepperoni. crumbly blue cheese and Parmesan cheese added after baked.
    $13.00+
  • Pizza of the Month

    The dirty Martini: Oil and garlic base, topped with roasted garlic, chopped martini olives and mozzarella. After baking, it is topped with blue cheese crumble.
    $14.00+
  • Taco

    Cheddar, taco seasoned beef, tomato, black olive, and jalapeño. Chilled iceburg lettuce topped after baking
    $14.00+

Sides

  • Blue Cheese Side

    $0.75
  • Medium sauce

    $0.75
  • Ranch

    $0.75
  • BBQ

    $0.75
  • chipotle ranch

    $0.75
  • 1000 Island

    $0.75
  • hot honey

    $0.75
  • Mild sauce

    $0.75
  • Hot sauce

    $0.75
  • country sweet

    $0.75

Spin Art Dip

$10.00

creamy dip topped with mozzarella cheese and baked. Served with tortilla chips

Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Buffalo Brothers Cary Locations and Hours

11735 RETAIL DRIVE

(919) 570-6004
11735 RETAIL DRIVE, WAKE FOREST, NC 27587
Closed
View menu

Alex's Place

(585) 344-2999
8322 Park Road, Batavia, NY 14020
Open now • Closes at 9PM
View menu

Buffalo Brothers Capital

(919) 878-4800
3111 CAPITAL BLVD, RALEIGH, NC 27604
Open now • Closes at 11PM
View menu

Buffalo Brothers Cary

(919) 561-5933
1289 KILDAIRE FARM RD, CARY, NC 27511
Closed • Opens Tuesday at 4PM
View menu

Buffalo Brothers Garner

(919) 615-0667
7245 WHITE OAK RD, GARNER, NC 27529
Open now • Closes at 2AM
View menu

Buffalo Brothers Lake Boone Trail

(919) 782-4949
4025 LAKE BOONE TRAIL #100, RALEIGH, NC 27607
Open now • Closes at 11PM
View menu

Eli Fish Brewing Co.

(585) 343-0008
109 Main Street, Batavia, NY 14020-2110
Open now • Closes at 3AM
View menu

Matty's Pizza

(585) 345-9909
109 Main Street, Batavia, NY 14020
Open now • Closes at 3:59AM
View menu
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement