Skip to Main content
Matty's Pizza is back!!
  • Buffalo Brothers Cary

Banner image

Matty's Pizza

109 Main Street, Batavia, NY
Change location
‌
‌
Appetizers
Wings
Pizza
Specialty Pizza
Sides

Featured Items

  • Small Cheese Pizza

    10" Pizza with mozzarella cheese
    $10.50
  • BBQ Chicken

    Buttermilk ranch base with mozzarella and cheddar cheeses, grilled chicken, bacon, and drizzled with BBQ sauce
    $14.00+
  • Mozzarella sticks w\marinara

    5 homemade mozzarella sticks served with warm marinara on side.
    $12.00

Appetizers

  • Stuffed Jalapenos

    Fresh jalapeno peppers stuffed with cream cheese, cheddar, and bacon. Drizzled with hot honey and chipotle ranch dressing
    $9.00
  • Stuffed Mushrooms

    Mushroom caps stuffed with spinach and Artichoke dip topped with mozzarella cheese and baked
    $9.00
  • Spin Art Dip

    creamy dip topped with mozzarella cheese and baked. Served with tortilla chips
    $10.00
  • Mozzarella sticks w\marinara

    5 homemade mozzarella sticks served with warm marinara on side.
    $12.00
  • Tennessee honey mozzarella sticks w\ranch

    our homemade mozzarella sticks dipped in our sweet and spicy Tennessee honey sauce served with a side of ranch for dipping.
    $14.00
  • Hand Battered Tender Platter w/fries(no substitutions)

    5 Hand battered chicken tenders served with fries(no substitutions) and blue cheese. Comes with your choice of dipping sauce on the side.
    $15.00

Wings

  • 10 Chicken Wings

    Ten deep fried chicken wings, tossed in your choice of wing sauce, served with blue cheese dressing.
    $15.00
  • 20 Chicken Wings

    Twenty deep fried chicken wings, tossed in your choice of wing sauce, served with blue cheese dressing.
    $28.00

Pizza

  • Small Cheese Pizza

    10" Pizza with mozzarella cheese
    $10.50
  • Large Cheese Pizza

    14" Pizza with mozzarella cheese
    $17.25

Specialty Pizza

  • Double Decker

    Double decker pizza: thin crust topped with buffalo sauce, crispy chicken and mozzarella, topped with another thin crust, red sauce, more mozzarella and pepperoni.
    $18.00+
  • BBQ Chicken

    Buttermilk ranch base with mozzarella and cheddar cheeses, grilled chicken, bacon, and drizzled with BBQ sauce
    $14.00+
  • Buffalo Chicken

    Blue cheese base with chicken fingers, mozzarella cheese, and medium wing sauce
    $13.00+
  • Ero's Pizza

    Traditional red sauce and mozzarella, topped with pepperoni, ham, and banana peppers
    $13.00+
  • Four Cheese Steak

    Olive oil base with chopped steak, a four cheese blend of mozzarella, Swiss, American, and cheddar. Topped with mushrooms, onions, and banana peppers
    $15.00+
  • Greek

    Ricotta and olive oil base with mozzarella and feta cheese, topped with Greek olive salad, artichoke hearts, tomato, and onion
    $13.00+
  • Hot Piggies

    Traditional red sauce and mozzarella topped with pepperoni, bacon, hot cherry and jalapeno peppers, and drizzled with hot honey
    $13.00+
  • Mac Attack

    White Base with American, cheddar, hamburger, onion, tomato, and 1000 island drizzle. Chilled iceburg lettuce topped after baking
    $13.00+
  • Pickle Pizza

    Ricotta and olive oil base with mozzarella, pickle chips, and fresh dill
    $13.00+
  • Stinger

    Blue cheese base with American Swiss and cheddar cheeses, chicken fingers, and steak. Topped with buffalo sauce drizzle.
    $15.00+
  • Stuffed Pepper

    Ricotta and olive oil base with mozzarella, Hungarian peppers, and Italian sausage
    $13.00+
  • Supreme

    Mozzarella cheese with pepperoni, mushrooms, onion, and Italian sausage
    $13.00+
  • Veggie

    Ricotta and olive oil base with mozzarella, mushroom, black olive, spinach, and tomato
    $13.00+
  • Country Sweet Pizza

    Country sweet, chicken tenders, mozzarella and bacon pieces
    $14.00+
  • Aaron Special

    A-A-Ron special: buffalo-garlic parm sauce for the base, topped with mozzarella cheese and cup and char pepperoni. crumbly blue cheese and Parmesan cheese added after baked.
    $13.00+
  • Pizza of the Month

    The dirty Martini: Oil and garlic base, topped with roasted garlic, chopped martini olives and mozzarella. After baking, it is topped with blue cheese crumble.
    $14.00+
  • Taco

    Cheddar, taco seasoned beef, tomato, black olive, and jalapeño. Chilled iceburg lettuce topped after baking
    $14.00+

Sides

  • Blue Cheese Side

    $0.75
  • Medium sauce

    $0.75
  • Ranch

    $0.75
  • BBQ

    $0.75
  • chipotle ranch

    $0.75
  • 1000 Island

    $0.75
  • hot honey

    $0.75
  • Mild sauce

    $0.75
  • Hot sauce

    $0.75
  • country sweet

    $0.75

Double Decker

$0.00

Double decker pizza: thin crust topped with buffalo sauce, crispy chicken and mozzarella, topped with another thin crust, red sauce, more mozzarella and pepperoni.

Customize your item

Size

Required
Select 1
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Buffalo Brothers Cary Locations and Hours

11735 RETAIL DRIVE

(919) 570-6004
11735 RETAIL DRIVE, WAKE FOREST, NC 27587
Closed
View menu

Alex's Place

(585) 344-2999
8322 Park Road, Batavia, NY 14020
Open now • Closes at 9PM
View menu

Buffalo Brothers Capital

(919) 878-4800
3111 CAPITAL BLVD, RALEIGH, NC 27604
Open now • Closes at 11PM
View menu

Buffalo Brothers Cary

(919) 561-5933
1289 KILDAIRE FARM RD, CARY, NC 27511
Closed • Opens Tuesday at 4PM
View menu

Buffalo Brothers Garner

(919) 615-0667
7245 WHITE OAK RD, GARNER, NC 27529
Open now • Closes at 2AM
View menu

Buffalo Brothers Lake Boone Trail

(919) 782-4949
4025 LAKE BOONE TRAIL #100, RALEIGH, NC 27607
Open now • Closes at 11PM
View menu

Eli Fish Brewing Co.

(585) 343-0008
109 Main Street, Batavia, NY 14020-2110
Open now • Closes at 3AM
View menu

Matty's Pizza

(585) 345-9909
109 Main Street, Batavia, NY 14020
Open now • Closes at 3:59AM
View menu
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement